20-Year Art Heist Case Concludes with Final Suspect’s Surrender
The Crime
Over the past two decades, a group of nine individuals, including Nicholas Dombek, has been involved in an elaborate art theft scheme that spanned multiple states. Prosecutors allege that the suspects orchestrated a series of break-ins at museums and other institutions, targeting valuable artwork, sports memorabilia, and cultural artifacts. Among the stolen items were pieces by renowned artists Andy Warhol and Jackson Pollock.
The Investigation
Authorities believe that the suspects conducted reconnaissance missions to gather information about the security measures at their targets. They would then return when the facilities were closed, using disguises and brute force to gain entry and steal the desired objects. The list of stolen items is extensive, including nine of Yogi Berra’s World Series rings, a Tiffany lamp, gold nuggets, antique firearms, jewelry, and numerous sports trophies.
The Suspects
In June 2023, prosecutors filed charges against all nine suspects. Dombek, who had been considered a fugitive for over six months, surrendered on Monday at the Lackawanna County Prison in Scranton, Pennsylvania. He was denied bail at his first court appearance and remains in custody. Four of the other suspects—Daryl Rinker, Ralph Parry, Frank Tassiello, and Thomas Trotta—have pleaded guilty. Damien Boland, Alfred Atsus, and Joseph Atsus have entered not-guilty pleas.
The Stolen Goods
Authorities are still searching for many of the stolen items. Some of the stolen goods were reportedly melted down and sold as metal discs or bars in New York City. Prosecutors allege that Dombek’s home in northeastern Pennsylvania was used for this process. They also claim that he burned a Jasper Cropsey painting worth approximately $500,000 to prevent it from being used as evidence.
The Mystery
The whereabouts of Dombek during the six months he was a fugitive remain unknown. His attorney, Ernie Preate, has stated that Dombek has been in the area and contacted him on New Year’s Day to express his desire to turn himself in. It is unclear what Dombek has been doing during this time.
The Ongoing Case
The remaining suspects in the case continue to make court appearances. State police have seized nearly 200 guns from Rinker’s home. The investigation and legal proceedings are ongoing, and it is likely that more details will emerge as the case progresses.
